Animal Advocate Calls Blind Guide Dog Users Cruel & Unfit, PETA, Off-Base Or Playing to Public Fear?

“We oppose most seeing-eye-dog programs,” says Daphna Nachminovitch, vice president for Cruelty Investigations for People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), in a January 10th interview with the LA Times’ “LA Unleashed.”

Nachminovitch’s objections go beyond PETA’s distaste for breeding programs. “They are kept in harnesses almost 24/7, people are prohibited from petting or playing with them and they cannot romp and run and interact with other dogs.” PETA also claims that schools force blind people to return their retired dogs.

Nachminovitch doubts the fitness of most blind people to care for their animals, “A deaf person can see if a dog has a medical issue such as blood in her urine, a blind person living alone cannot.” PETA’s solution would return blind people to lives of dependence; “The human community should do more to support blind people, and give dogs a break. .”

Outraged guide dog handlers and puppy raisers from many schools commented on refuting every point. Letters to the editor and Op-Ed pieces were submitted to the Los Angeles Times. Some people, like Tampa-based clinical hypnotherapist, professional musician and speaker Marion Gwizdala,, president of the National Association of Guide Dog Users (NAGDU), wrote to Nachminovitch directly.

“The biggest problem we face as blind people,” writes Gwizdala, who holds a Master of Science degree in mental health counseling and has been in practice since 1996, “is misunderstanding and lack of information. It is unfortunate that you choose to promulgate the myths that create barriers to our full inclusion in society. “

Are Nachminovitch’s comments adding to an underlying bigotry toward blind people? Unemployment among working-age blind Americans is seventy percent. Blind Americans are also more likely to be underemployed and living in poverty. Nonetheless, there are blind lawyers, engineers, chemists, doctors, mechanics, teachers, parents, etc.

Why the disparity? Many believe that it all boils down to the changing nature of what it means to be blind. Throughout history, there have always been blind people who have insisted upon living productive and independent lives. The ancient Greek poet Homer, English poet John Milton and American author James Thurber were all blind. Most Americans are familiar with the accomplishments of Helen Keller. The fact, however, that she is the only blind woman most people can name and that she died over fifty years ago speaks volumes about the added obstacles society places in the paths of blind women.

PETA’s solution of having sighted people take over for guide dogs, insulting as it is, simply mirrors the prevailing social attitudes. Despite changes in legislation and a revolution in technology which allows blind people to participate more fully in all aspects of modern life, popular sentiment continues to paint blindness as a sentence to dependence and uselessness. The truth came out in a Louis Harris poll done in 1991. The National Organization on Disability (NOD) commissioned them to find out what America really thought about people with disabilities. The survey summary, quoted from NOD’s 1992 book “That All May Worship,” edited by Ginny Thornburgh, states, “The public views disabled people as fundamentally different than the rest of the population, feeling admiration and pity most often. Embarrassment, apathy and fear are also common.”

We will probably never know PETA’s true motivations for making these statements. Nachminovitch’s remarks are so all-inclusive, so concise and so thoroughly off-base that it is hard to believe they were not deliberately calculated to prompt donations from dog lovers who are either unfamiliar with guide dog programs or uncomfortable with blind people and misinformed about their capabilities. It is possible, of course, that she nurtures a habit of willful ignorance and is not inclined to investigate anything she speaks about. In either case, PETA’s bullying of blind people seems a waste of resources.

The thought that schools would force blind people to give up their beloved helpers is anathema to many guide dog users. Schools have retirement programs but they are voluntary. They exist to take up the slack in cases where a blind person can neither keep their retired guide nor find a suitable home among friends and family.

“More often than not,” Gwizdala continues, “our dogs live out their lives with their blind caretakers. My previous guide dog worked until he was fourteen years old and lived out the remainder of his sixteen years with me.”

Gwizdala, who is also the music director at New Life Unity Church in Tampa, is working with Louiza, his twelve-year-old German Shepherd/Collie mix. He performs under the stage name “Marion & Martin” – a reference to his Martin guitar – and is recording his second solo album, a collection of original songs, covers and contemporary arrangements of traditional music in the new thought genre. Visit NAGDU’s web site at:

Cheryl Echevarria (42) of Long Island, New York is a certified medical insurance specialist and medical biller. Maxx, her three-year-old black Labrador retriever from the Guide Dog Foundation for the Blind (Smithtown, NY), is Cheryl’s first guide dog.

“Hold on there,” she says in response to PETA’s idea that guide dogs aren’t given any affection and are forced to wear their harnesses 24/7, “Yes I use my dog when I walk to the bus and go out shopping, or any place I go to be independent. But even when I am at work, Maxx has a nice comfy spot under my desk. No, he doesn’t need to be tied down, and no, he doesn’t sit there all day with his harness on. I take it off and he sleeps or chews on his bone until I need to go somewhere with him.”

Cheryl works at Sunrise Medical and was the first visually impaired person to graduate from Branford Hall Career Institute in medical billing. She is a member of New York’s Association of Guide Dog Users, and treasurer of the Greater Long Island chapter of the National Federation of the Blind of New York.

She recently started a free group for one of her favorite activities, cooking. The Blind Cooks e mail list is a place where people can exchange ideas about techniques, equipment, accessibility issues and other topics of interest to blind cooks as well as professionals in the culinary arts and those who wish to enter the field. For more information go to,

Guide dog schools all teach handlers not to allow people to pet the dogs when in harness. There is a difference between work and play, and it is safer when people respect that. Guide dog handlers regularly report that people approach them while the dog is in harness and pet the dog without even saying hello. Most people ask to pet an unfamiliar dog and respect the person’s wishes. If they say no, they don’t pet the dog anyway or assume that no one ever pets that particular dog. The fact that this is what happens when strangers encounter guide dogs is evidence that blind people are not respected as independent adults.

“When we are home,” says Echevarria, who has a twenty-year-old daughter, three grown stepchildren and four grandchildren, “he runs around the house like any dog. Plays in the backyard, and gets spoiled by my husband and my daughter and any friends that come in contact with us.”

Cheryl, who is legally blind due to diabetic retinopathy, had a kidney transplant from a living donor in 2005. She belongs to the Diabetic Action network (DAN). DAN is a resource for all diabetics especially those with vision loss. Blind diabetics can and do accurately draw up insulin and monitor blood glucose levels.

Are blind people, many of whom monitor their own serious health conditions like diabetes, unqualified to meet the health needs of their dogs as PETA implies? The comments made to me by my first guide’s vet in Philadelphia echo across the decades. One of his professors at the University of Pennsylvania’s School of Veterinary Medicine said that if a blind person brings in their guide dog and tells you they think something’s wrong and you can’t find anything, keep looking.

For a less anecdotal and more current perspective, we need look no further than the November 2008 report “Guide Dog Health Survey” by the Morris Animal Foundation (MAF). MAF, which was started in 1948 as the Buddy Foundation to address the health needs of the first guide dog, has since funded over 1,600 research studies benefiting animals around the world. Concerned that health information for adult guide dogs was scarce, they conducted a survey, not of veterinarians, spouses, parents or the lady down the street but of guide dog users themselves. It is the first of its kind and intended to serve as a base-line for future surveys. Their care in preparing and pre-testing an online survey that was easy for screen reader users to complete was matched by not only the breadth of the study but the many opportunities for guide dog users to comment freely about their concerns and experiences.

The 1,000+ survey participants gave over 11,500 open-ended comments, prompting the report’s author, Patricia Olson, DVM, Ph.D. (MAF’s President/CEO), to write, “Guide dog teams have been referred to as the gold standard for a bond between a person and his or her dog. Handlers provide love and care to their dogs; the dogs provide independence and loyalty to their handler. The overwhelming response to the survey made it abundantly clear just how much guide dog handlers appreciate and love their dogs. Any work that allows these wonderful teams to enjoy even better health and wellness is very important to MAF.”

Blind people share PETA’s concern for unwanted dogs. PETA, however, doesn’t acknowledge that most guide dog schools have already tried using shelter dogs. Too many shelter dogs failed the programs, adding to the cost of training. Breeding programs provide healthier dogs with the aptitude and temperament for the work. Guide dogs perform advanced tasks, avoiding overhanging obstacles, navigating public transportation and moving safely through crowded pedestrian and vehicular traffic. They can find specific locations, when trained with patience and praise.

Here again, comments from MAF’s survey underscore the validity of dedicated breeding programs, “In fact, guide dog schools have often been a model for evaluating health trends and reducing disease through appropriate breeding.”

A form letter from Heidi Parker, PETA’s Mail Coordinator, sent to people like Gwizdala and myself, back-pedals on Nachminovitch’s remarks. “Our comments were not meant to reflect badly on people who use or train guide dogs.”

One wonders whether Ms Parker actually read her boss’s remarks. If she did, what else does she think Nachminovitch would have had to say, if she had “intended” to reflect badly on guide dog programs and those who benefit from them? From the selfless people who raise them as puppies – the family of the Hudson River hero pilot Sully Sullenberger among them – to the volunteers in the kennels and the trainers themselves, many dog lovers participate in the care and training of guide dogs. If cruelty was endemic in the programs, wouldn’t someone have spoken out before now?

Echevarria has some advice for the LA Times, “people who write such articles should go to the schools and speak to the professionals about the training.” She also has parting thoughts for PETA, “I hope you never go blind and need a dog. I also say that you should learn from the experts before you open your mouths and stick your foot in.”

PETA has not seen fit to make a public apology, and the LA Times has yet to respond.

Copyright 2009 by Donna W. Hill

Source by Donna W. Hill

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

You may also like




World economies have recognized Information Technology as an effective tool in catalyzing the economic activity in efficient governance and in developing human resource. They have made significant investments in it and successfully integrated it with the development process, thereby reaping the benefits to their society. In India also, these developments have impacted the industrial, education, service and Government sectors and their influence on various applications is increasingly being felt of


As the era of digital economy is evolving, the concept of governance has assumed significant importance. The e-Governance has consequently become an accepted methodology involving the use of Information Technology in improving transparency, providing information speedily to all citizens, improving administration efficiency and improving public services such as transportation, power, health, water, security and municipal services.

India has been harnessing the benefits provided by the Information & Communication

Technologies to provide integrated governance, reach to the citizens faster,provide efficient services and citizen…

Read More

5 Basics To Protect Your Health During A Pandemic

This year, 2020, will be remembered, unfortunately, as the year of this horrific pandemic, which has seen over 50 million worldwide cases, and over 10 million cases in the United States, as well as about a million deaths, throughout the world, and nearly 250, 000 fatalities, in this nation. Some articulate, a variety of inane concepts, and theories, including, herd immunity, pandemic – fatigue, or, it will all go away, by itself, etc, but, if we wish, to address this virus, and begin to reduce the public health risks, we need to take personal responsibility, to protect our health, and well – being, during a pandemic. With that in mind, this article will attempt to, briefly, consider, examine, review, and discuss, 5 basic steps, to achieve this.

1. Wear a mask: Why has wearing a mask, become a political discussion? Nearly, every public health expert, states, if, everyone, simply wore…

Read More

Introducing Mauritius

One captivating island that is not yet discovered by a lot of people is Mauritius Island. Although not as popular as the other islands in the world, Mauritius has its own promise of enchantment you would not want to miss.

Mauritius is an island in the Indian Ocean. It is located off the coast of Africa and lies east of Madagascar. Long before it was named after Prince Maurice, who was the Prince of Orange and Count of Nassau, it were the Arab traders who set foot on this island back in the 10th century. However, it was the culture of the Dutch that made great influence on the island when they used it as a supply base. When the Dutch decided to desert the island, the French came. Then the British got hold of the island through the Treaty of Paris before they finally became independent in 1968.

Due to…

Read More

Ten Steps to Improve Hospitality Communication

You’re celebrating your anniversary at a nice restaurant, you order your favorite meal, it’s going to be a wonderful night… but the waiter is in a bad mood, the order is late, and the food is not what you wanted, you can hear an argument in the kitchen… You won’t be going to that restaurant again, and you’ll tell all your friends too.

Bad communication is bad news anywhere, and in the hospitality industry in particular. So how can we prevent Hospitality communication calamities?

1. Have well-trained staff. If you can’t hire well trained staff, find people who are keen workers and willing to learn, and train them yourself. In fact, some employers prefer to train their own staff, rather than re-train experienced staff to meet their standards. Well trained staff is the key to providing professional service.

2. Hospitality is all about service; stress that to your staff. Hospitality staff often…

Read More

Perth International Airport

Hire Car At Your Fingertip

Perth International Airport Background

The 4th busiest airport in Australia, Perth international airport is situated just outside Perth in Australia. It has three terminals – an international terminal (T1) and two domestic terminals (T2&T3). The building of the international terminal is located 17km from Central Perth and the two domestic terminals about 12 km from the main district of the city.

Perth City

Perth is the capital of Western Australia, which is Australia’s largest state. Interestingly, Perth is geographically closer to East Timor and Jakarta, Indonesia, than to Sydney, Melbourne, and Brisbane.

Perth is nestled in the Swan river, which flows back to the Indian ocean. Perth has the most captivating beaches in Australia.

Tourists’ Itch

As you land in one of the three airport terminals, we can understand the tourist(s) itch you must be having on your feet to explore and get a feel of this beautiful Australian city. You…

Read More

How to Become a Journalist

Journalism is a very competitive field and one of the most exciting as well. If you love to gather interesting information, analyzing and reporting them and disseminating them to the general public, then a journalism career is for you. Journalism jobs in London are in demand as media companies and publishing houses are always on the lookout for fresh journalists.

Journalism jobs vary but the most popular include working in a newspaper or broadcasting station. Entry level positions for fresh graduates are available in these job sectors. Once you’ve gained experience or had taken advance courses in journalism, you can land better jobs as a reporter, commentator, sports and weathercaster, and anchor. Others become news writers, columnists, and correspondents.

Educational Requirements

Journalists must possess exemplary knowledge and skills in the English language. They have to be proficient in both written and oral communication. As such, they must have a degree in English…

Read More

Seychelles Vacation – The Best Time For Your Travel to Seychelles

When is the best time for a holiday in Seychelles? This is a question I get asked very often. And the answer really is an issue that has nothing to do with Seychelles at all. First, I must say, for a vacation in Seychelles there is no “best time” of year. It is pleasant 365 days in these islands. So…

Right now with prices being low, not cheap but definitely more affordable if you’re on a budget, now is a very good time for that Seychelles holiday. But before you rush off to buy a ticket to Seychelles today I would suggest you plan well and you keep yourself informed of special offers, especially during the off-season.

Why the off-season? It is because that might be the very best time for your own holiday depending on your situation. Knowing all that will ensure the very best holiday in Seychelles for you….

Read More

Discover the Beauty of Dominica by Planning a Vacation

A proper plan is necessary for almost anything. Even if you want to lead a successful and happy life you need to plan it properly. Similarly of you want to go for a vacation you need to plan it in the best possible way. Planning can sometimes seem to be a bit tough because there are so many things to consider.

When you plan for a vacation the first thing that you need to do is plan your budget. You need to find out how much you will be able to spend and depending on that you need to take the other decisions. You must always remember that some places are more costly than the others. If you are looking forward to spend some time on a wonderful beach then you can think about choosing Dominica. The Dominican islands are also called the nature islands because of the natural beauty…

Read More